However, on Lily’s second birthday, Kyle’s world was shaken when a woman, Cherish Vegas, showed up at his door, claiming to be Lily’s biological mother. She admitted to abandoning her on Kyle’s doorstep two years earlier and wanted her back. Cherish explained that her boyfriend, Burt, had recently signed a major league contract and was now wealthy—she wanted to use the child to secure her financial future.Kyle was furious but refused to give Lily up. The woman didn’t seem to have any real attachment to her daughter and only saw her as a way to profit. A week later, Cherish filed a case in family court, contesting Kyle’s adoption of Lily. Social services began to investigate him, and Kyle found his life under a microscope,
At the court hearing, Cherish and Burt argued for custody, but the judge exposed their true motives. When the judge asked Burt if he was prepared to be a father, Burt hesitated, and Cherish declared that the baby would bring in money thanks to Burt’s contract. But when the judge asked Cherish for Lily’s name, Cherish faltered, unsure of what to say. That was when Kyle stood up and declared that Lily was his daughter, and her name was Lily Greenbecker.As Kyle spoke, Lily, who had been playing with the social worker, suddenly cried out “Daddy!” and reached for him. The judge, moved by the child’s clear attachment to Kyle, ruled in his favor. Cherish’s claims were dismissed, and Kyle’s adoption of Lily was confirmed.That night, Kyle celebrated his victory with Lily, and the two spent the evening catching lightning bugs in the garden. Kyle realized that, despite all the challenges and the pain of losing Lisa, the brightest star in his life was his little girl, and nothing would ever take her away from him.