Accusations flew until Barbara revealed the truth: the father wasn’t Josh, but Josh’s father, Andrew. Months earlier, during a family gathering, Barbara and Andrew had drunkenly hooked up. Ashamed and scared, Barbara had kept it secret, not wanting to destroy her daughter’s marriage.Once the truth came out,
Melanie apologized. Andrew, shocked but willing to step up, visited Barbara in the hospital—with a proposal. They married soon after, and despite the rocky start, the unconventional family found a way to move forward—together.